Submit a single chapter and Scout gives you a complete professional critique — every dimension of craft assessed, every problem paired with a concrete fix. Honest. Specific. Actionable.
From strengths to conclusion. No generic feedback. No softened truths. A real editorial critique from a working editor with 22 years of experience.
Scout assesses each section with specific evidence from your text. Nothing is glossed over. Nothing is invented.
Tell Scout your genre, where this chapter sits in the manuscript, and your draft stage. Paste any context they need.
Paste your chapter text directly into the chat. Scout reads it in full before beginning the critique.
Scout works through all fourteen sections with specific evidence from your text. No generic feedback — every observation is anchored in your actual words.
Every observation is anchored in specific lines, scenes, or passages from your chapter. Scout quotes your work. No vague generalisations.
Every problem identified is paired with a concrete direction for fixing it. "The dialogue is weak" is not a critique — "the exchange on page 4 is on-the-nose; here's what subtext might look like" is.
If it's working, Scout says so. If it's not, Scout says that too — clearly, without cruelty, without softening it past the point of usefulness.
The Potential Improvements section is sorted into Critical (must fix), Important (significantly improves), and Refinements (polish). You know where to start.
A literary fiction chapter and a thriller chapter are assessed by different standards. Scout knows the difference and applies the right lens.
Paste your chapter into the chat. Scout asks a few quick questions, then delivers a complete 14-section critique. Specific, honest, actionable.
Submit your chapter directly in the chat interface. Payment via Stripe.
We use analytics to understand how authors find us and improve the site. No manuscript content is ever tracked. Privacy policy