A vanity press charges authors money to publish their books while retaining a share of royalties, rights or both. The clearest definition: if a publisher is asking you for money to publish your book but also keeping some of the royalties, that is a vanity press. If you pay all costs yourself and keep all royalties, that is self-publishing. If the publisher pays you an advance, covers all production costs and takes most of the royalties, that is traditional publishing. The vanity press occupies an exploitative middle position that delivers the worst outcomes of both other models.

The Red Flags

Unsolicited Contact

They found you and contacted you without any submission from you. Major publishers and legitimate literary agents do not cold-call or email random authors. An unsolicited approach expressing enthusiasm about your book is a sales pitch, not a publishing offer.

Promise of Publication Without Rejection

"We would love to publish your book" after a brief exchange is not a compliment. Legitimate publishers reject the vast majority of manuscripts they receive. An offer that comes before any serious editorial assessment is a commercial proposition, not a publishing decision.

Upfront Fees Combined with Royalty Claims

Asking for money to publish your book while also retaining royalty percentages is the defining vanity press structure. Some Australian vanity presses charge AUD $8,000 to $15,000 upfront with no meaningful marketing commitment and retain rights on top of that fee.

Fake Testimonials or Credentials

Australian researchers at Deakin University identified vanity publishers in 2025 using fake author testimonials, AI-generated images and fraudulently claiming to publish legitimately held Australian titles. Search for reviews of any publisher outside their own website before engaging.

Retaining Full Rights

Any publisher asking for worldwide exclusive rights in all formats in perpetuity, in exchange for a paying-to-publish arrangement, is operating predatorily. Rights reversion clauses — which specify when and how you can get your rights back — are essential in any publishing contract. If there is no clear reversion clause, do not sign.

Australian Scams Targeting Local Authors

Active and Documented Australian Scams (2025)

Operations using names including "Book Publisher Sydney Book," "Aussie Publisher" and "Oz Book Publishers" were identified in 2025 as impersonating legitimate Australian publishing firms. One operation used the ABN of reputable Melbourne publisher Melbourne Books under the deceptive name "Melbourne Book Publisher." Writer Beware has also documented Love of Books Brisbane (operated by "Julie McGregor") in their scam archive. As of May 2026, Writer Beware additionally warns of AI-driven impersonation scams using the names of real publishing industry professionals to approach authors with fraudulent interest.

Legitimate Watchdog Resources

Writer Beware (writerbeware.blog)

The most comprehensive English-language database of publishing scams, maintained by the Science Fiction and Fantasy Writers of America (SFWA). Search any publisher or agent you are considering.

Australian Society of Authors

Provides contract review services and can advise on specific publishers before you sign anything. This service is available to members.

Preditors and Editors

A database of publishing industry professionals with community-contributed reviews and warnings.

Questions to Ask Before Signing Anything

Ask these questions directly and verify the answers independently

Do you pay the author an advance, or does the author pay you?
What percentage of royalties do you retain?
Who owns the rights to the book after publication, the author or the publisher?
Can I see a list of books you have published and contact those authors directly?
What distribution channels will my book be available through and what does that actually mean for retail availability?
What does the contract say about rights reversion — under what conditions and timeline can I get my rights back?

Self-publishing gives you full control and full royalties — if the manuscript is ready.

Wild Hearts Publishing's AI manuscript review gives you an independent assessment before you commit to any publishing path. From $149 AUD. You retain 100% of your rights.

Review My Manuscript →

Vanity Press Red Flags: How to Spot a Publisher That Will Take Your Money and Your Rights